E-commerce

Adobe Commerce or Shopify Plus: How to Choose for Your Online Store

Adobe Commerce vs Shopify Plus: differences in control, cost, integrations, B2B and maintenance, and the criteria for choosing the right platform.

Area
E-commerce
Published
November 16, 2026
Reading time
5 minutes

In this guide

What you will find

Shopify Plus is the faster choice to launch and run when your needs fit within the platform's features; Adobe Commerce is the right choice when you need highly customised business logic and full control of code and infrastructure. In the "adobe commerce vs shopify plus" comparison there is no absolute winner: what matters is your catalogue, your processes, the integrations with your internal systems and the team that will have to evolve the store.

Adobe Commerce and Shopify Plus in brief

Adobe Commerce (the platform that started as Magento) is highly extensible software with APIs, a module system and features for B2B and B2C. Adobe also offers it as a service: its developer portal lists Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service and extension tools such as App Builder.

Shopify Plus is Shopify's enterprise plan: a hosted platform where infrastructure, security and updates are handled by Shopify. Shopify's site presents it with checkout, B2B features and a built-in AI assistant, but those are vendor claims: compare them with your own needs rather than treating them as a benchmark.

The criteria for choosing

1. How unusual your sales process is

Customer-specific prices, complex price lists, availability rules, quotes, approval flows: if your business model is out of the ordinary, Adobe Commerce leaves more room because the logic is written in the store's code. Shopify Plus covers many cases with its native features and apps, and for deeper customisation it offers Shopify Functions: code that changes the logic of discounts, payment and delivery options, checkout validation and more. Custom apps with Functions are restricted to stores on a Plus plan.

2. Who looks after infrastructure and maintenance

With Shopify Plus, hosting, security and platform updates are Shopify's responsibility. With Adobe Commerce, unless you choose a managed service, someone has to take care of servers, patches, performance and backups. It is an extra responsibility, but also freedom of configuration. That is why having a partner who follows the store after launch matters: with us that is the job of DNA Support and DNA Hosting.

3. Integrations with ERP, management systems and marketplaces

Both platforms integrate with management systems, PIM and marketplaces through APIs. Adobe Commerce gives more room for deep, two-way integrations; Shopify Plus has an ecosystem of ready-made apps that shortens the time for standard cases. If your management system is unusual, a small intermediate service is sometimes the better option: in our projects we use Laravel microservices. In the Semprefarmacia case study, on Magento 2, we integrated Axerve for payments, Feedaty for reviews, ShippyPro for shipping, Lengow for marketplaces and Doofinder for internal search.

4. Frontend and release speed

On Adobe Commerce the frontend can be built with Hyvä, a theme designed to be lighter than the Luma theme. On Shopify you work with Shopify's own theme system. In both cases the theme is a project decision, not a detail: it affects timelines, maintenance costs and performance.

5. Total cost

The comparison has to be made on total cost, not on the licence: initial development, fees, apps, hosting, maintenance, evolution. The sources you find online give very different figures, often from agencies that sell one of the two solutions, which is why we do not quote them: a serious comparison is made on a concrete scope, with a quote for each option.

When to lean towards Adobe Commerce

  • a very large catalogue and complex pricing or availability rules;
  • deep integrations with ERP and internal systems;
  • a need to control code, hosting and data;
  • B2B with unusual flows;
  • a team or partner able to maintain the platform.

When to lean towards Shopify Plus

  • priority on a fast start and simple management;
  • processes that fit within native features or existing apps;
  • a wish not to deal with infrastructure;
  • an in-house team that manages catalogue and promotions independently.

One often-overlooked point: moving from one platform to the other later is possible but it is a real project, with catalogue, customers, orders and redirects to carry over. It is better to choose with the next few years in mind, not only the launch.

Three questions before deciding

  1. Which rules of your business cannot be simplified without losing margin or customers?
  2. Which internal systems must talk to the store in real time?
  3. Who will look after the store every day, and in three years?

If the answers are "few rules, few systems, a small team", the lighter road is usually the better one.

How we do it

With Ecommerce Factory we build online stores on Adobe Commerce with a Hyvä frontend and on Shopify Plus, and we do not propose a platform before understanding your processes. An example on Adobe Commerce is the Antica Farmacia Orlandi case study.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can't find the answer? Write to us and we will get back to you.

Ask your question

Services

The services linked to the guide

  • Ecommerce Factory

    We design and build B2C and B2B online stores on Adobe Commerce (Magento) with Hyvä and on Shopify Plus: analysis, UX, development, integrations, go-live.

See all services

The DNAFactory service lines that put into practice what this guide explains.

Guides

More guides

How e-commerce platforms, custom management software and AI work and how to choose, from the people who work on them every day.

Contact us

We are ready to hear about your project

Tell us about your online store or your idea. One of our experts will get back to you within 24 hours.

Request a quote Or write to us at [email protected]